Hi Elizbeth
To try to answer some of the questions – goes on a bit I’m afraid (god, I do seem to talk a lot!).
Large growths of algae are usually the sign of an excess of nutrients – though in your case it’s difficult to know where they could have come from. Are you confident that your rainwater tank only has rainwater in it (sorry – I had to ask!).
And it is worth saying that, although garden ponds seem so familiar, we still know remarkably little about what makes them tick – and as you’ll know if you’ve been reading the blog, much of what is said about them has not much basis in fact. So with that caveat in mind…
It’s a little surprising that algae are growing quickly in your pond given that you’re pulling it out regularly – it does suggest some kind of excess of nutrients.
Are filamentous algae harmful to other plants and animals? Well, they’ll certainly compete with other submerged plants, and could in effect smother them. They probably wouldn’t do much harm to marginal plants.
They’re not what I would call harmful to animals – only in as much as they may limit the range of habitats available. And mats of algae often teem with creatures (and also have a forest of smaller algae growing on them) – so they make a pretty prodcutive kind of habitat for animals.
Is it the high temperatures that are making the algae proliferate? That will play a part – they’ll be able to grow faster – but what makes filamentous algae proliferate in small ponds is most probably a combination of excess nutrients and plenty of light (once again we have no controlled experiments to be sure of the answer – but that’s what experience seems to suggest).
We’ve never had any filamentous algae in my Old Pond – it’s low in nutrients and semi-shaded.
But now in the New Pond we do have filamentous algae – much to my surprise.
But then the other day we found that nutrient concentrations were actually rather high – at a level I would call pollution (I’ve no idea why because I thought we’d taken all necessary measures to keep nutrients low). Added to this the pond is in full sun all day long.
Are snails any use? Probably not. Snails are often hugely abundant in filamentous algae – they love it as a habitat! But the idea that they will control algae is, in my experience, one of those myths put about, I suspect, by people who want to sell you snails. Of course snails do browse algae (we’ve all seen the snail tracks on the side of an aquarium) but I’ve never seen a pond where, when polluting nutrients are in excess, snails can keep the algae down.
And the $64,000 question – What can I do to regulate the algae?
Well, that depends on the cause. If it’s nutrients – reduce nutrient levels.
If you’re really keen to find out, Pond Conservation supporters can get simple water testing to get you started – but to really know the nutrient levels in your pond you need a lab. water test. Contact my colleague Angela Julian for more information.
As for barley straw – it has some effect but it’s hit and miss (it doesn’t kill all algae) and it doesn’t cure the source of the problem – just temporarily kills the algae. It’s not a substitute for clean water.
You could simply do as Martin suggests and just wait and see what happens – but I would always aim for nutrient levels being near natural as the best way of ensuring limited growth of algae and the best range of wildlife in the pond.
In your case the question is – are nutrient levels as low as you hoped from using rainwater?